Julian’s Chaos Filter: How to Prioritize in the Second Era of Trumpian Sensationalism

6–9 minutes

·

·

In an era defined by political whiplash and political overload, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Every day brings a fresh headline: Trump wants to reopen Alcatraz as a prison. Trump posts an AI-generated image of himself as the Pope. Trump says inject bleach. Trump retweets conspiracy theories about lightbulbs or Taylor Swift. At first glance, much of it feels absurd, like outtakes from a failed Netflix reality series. But buried in the avalanche of chaos are actual, existential threats to American democracy—and to public education in particular.

So how do we know what to pay attention to?

This is not a rhetorical question. It’s an urgent one. In today’s political environment, not all news is equal. Not every Trumpian proclamation, meme, mental musing, or tantrum deserves our full attention. Some are distractions. Some are barometers. But others—especially those tied to irreversible policy changes—should shoot straight to the top of our collective priority list.

In a recent segment of The Daily Show, Jon Stewart hit the nail on the head. He mocked the blitzkrieg of nonsense streaming from the White House and conservative media, noting how difficult it has become to distinguish between spectacle and substance. His message wasn’t just about media literacy. It was about survival strategy. If we don’t learn how to filter the noise, we risk missing the signal—and the signal includes the dismantling of public education, civil rights, and democracy itself.

So let’s talk about how to prioritize in the chaos. What deserves urgent scrutiny? What can we set aside for now? How do we create a triage system for truth and outrage?


Not All Threats and Nonsense Are Created Equal

To be clear: Trump’s political strategy is not chaos for chaos’ sake. It’s purposeful. The constant stream of provocations, policy leaks, and incendiary comments functions like a military blitzkrieg—rapid, disorienting, and overwhelming. The goal is not to win on every front. It’s to exhaust our capacity to fight at all.

By flooding the media with nonsense—AI papal images, deranged Truth Social posts, performative fights with celebrities—Trump creates white noise that drowns out real dangers. While we’re laughing at a Trump-themed Super Bowl ad, his team is quietly gutting federal protections for students or appointing extremist ideologues to key education posts.

This is by design. In military strategy, it’s called “shock and awe.” In media theory, it’s the “outrage economy.” In clinical psychology, it’s gaslighting on a national scale.

We need to stop reacting to every headline as if it’s equal in consequence. We must distinguish between:

  • Symbolic distractions (e.g., memes, viral moments)
  • Ideological dog whistles (e.g., calls to “return prayer to schools”)
  • Legislative threats (e.g., plans to abolish the Department of Education)
  • Constitutional crises (e.g., Trump questioning whether he must “uphold” the Constitution)

Without this hierarchy, we risk spending our energy fighting shadows while the walls are being dismantled behind us.


The Continuum of Urgency: Julian’s Chaos Filter

Let’s build a rough continuum of priority—from red-alert threats to manageable absurdities.

Top Tier: Constitutional and Institutional Destruction

  • Trump saying he’s not sure if he’s obligated to uphold the Constitution. This isn’t just bluster. It’s a roadmap to authoritarianism. When a potential president expresses doubts about following the Constitution, that’s not theoretical—it’s foundational. If he’s not bound by it, nothing is off-limits.
  • Pledges to abolish the Department of Education. This would end federal oversight of civil rights enforcement, Title IX protections, special education services, and funding equity mandates. It’s the dream of extremists like Betsy DeVos and the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025—and it’s no longer hypothetical.
  • Executive Orders targeting entire academic institutions. If a Trump administration threatens to defund or investigate public universities or K-12 districts for ideological noncompliance, that’s an attack on academic freedom—and it will cascade into every space of schooling.
  • “Discussions” about suspending habeas corpus. This would allow the government to detain individuals indefinitely without trial—a move historically reserved for wartime crises. Floating this idea in peacetime is a chilling signal of how far Trump’s inner circle is willing to go to sidestep basic civil liberties and silence dissent.

These threats are systemic and have irreversible consequences if left unchecked. They demand our constant vigilance and highest priority.


Mid Tier: Ideological Engineering with Policy Teeth

  • Mandatory “patriotic” education. These proposals aim to rewrite U.S. history curricula, especially around race, slavery, and colonialism. Framed as “anti-woke,” these policies amount to federal and state-sponsored historical revisionism.
  • Book bans and curriculum restrictions. Often enacted at the state level, these bans have a chilling effect on both educators and students—particularly those from marginalized communities. Increasingly, the federal government is joining this effort, with growing threats to withhold funding as a means of enforcing ideological compliance.
  • Attacks on school diversity programs. DEI offices are being dismantled or defunded. Anti-affirmative action measures are spreading. These policies weaken the very structures that made school more equitable.

These policies may not consistently make national headlines like Trump’s wildest proclamations, but they are often more immediately harmful—and have permanence in their impact.


Low Tier: Cultural Performance and Distraction

  • AI-generated images of Trump as Jesus or Pope.
  • Calls to reopen Alcatraz.
  • Public feuds with celebrities, athletes, or cartoon characters.

These are distractions by design. They suck up media oxygen, dominate social feeds, and prompt think pieces galore—but they have no real policy impact. Let them pass. Laugh if you must. But don’t linger!


How Education Advocates Can Use the Julian Filter

So how do educators, activists, and policy analysts keep their heads in this whirlwind? By refusing to be reactive. Instead, we must ask a few core questions whenever a new Trump headline drops:

  1. Does this have legislative or executive consequences? Is this tweet going to become law? If not, it might not be worth our energy.
  2. Could this directly impact students, educators, or institutions? Who stands to lose access, safety, or dignity if this becomes reality?
  3. Is this an authoritarian move dressed as policy? When Trump talks about “restoring order” or “removing radicals,” it’s often code for using law enforcement to purge dissent.
  4. Is the media covering this in a way that ignores the deeper policy impact?Sometimes the story is buried beneath the headline. Don’t let sensationalism obscure the substance.

This framework allows us to allocate our outrage strategically. In the face of political arson, we need fire marshals—not just flame watchers.


When to Speak, When to Save Energy

This moment requires a kind of political mindfulness. We are not infinite in energy. Educators are already fighting book bans, budget cuts, state takeovers, and classroom censorship. We cannot afford to waste that energy on meme wars. That doesn’t mean we ignore culture entirely—it means we respond with intention, not instinct.

Trump wants to bait into distraction. Every absurd statement is another test of our attention span. Every press conference is a loyalty oath wrapped in provocation. But we must resist the trap.

Sometimes silence is strategic. Sometimes choosing not to share that outrageous clip on social media is the most radical act. Sometimes, the best response to chaos is clarity.

Let’s save our voices for the fights that matter. Let’s redirect our networks, our platforms, and our coalitions toward protecting public education from systemic dismantling—not temporary outrage bait.


What Deserves Our Megaphone

If you’re a school board member, a professor, a parent, or a student activist, your voice is precious. Use it for the threats that will define the next generation.

  • When Trump says he’ll abolish the Department of Education—speak up.
  • When executive orders punish universities for tolerating “unpatriotic” speech—resist.
  • When civil rights offices are defunded or converted into surveillance tools—organize.
  • When Trump says he won’t commit to the Constitution—raise hell.

These are the moments that should stop the presses. These are the red-alert headlines that must go viral. Everything else—no matter how wild—can wait.


From Chaos to Clarity

There’s no denying that second Trump-era politics are strategics designed to create an even greater torrent of absurdity, menace, and unpredictability. But if we learn to discern between smoke and fire, we can protect what matters. Public education—already fragile from decades of defunding and privatization—may not survive another term of policy by spectacle.

We must prioritize substance over sensationalism. That doesn’t mean ignoring the stakes—it means filtering them through a lens of long-term impact. Will this affect students? Will this dismantle institutions? Will this redefine rights?

If yes, we act. If no, we move on.

Let the chaos swirl. Let the memes fly. But keep your eyes on the real battle.

In an era defined by political whiplash and political overload, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Every day brings a fresh headline: Trump wants to reopen Alcatraz as a prison. Trump posts an AI-generated image of himself as the Pope. Trump says inject bleach. Trump retweets conspiracy theories about lightbulbs or Taylor Swift. At first glance,…

Leave a comment

Cloaking Inequity is an online platform for justice and liberty-minded readers. I publish reflections, analysis, and commentary on education, democracy, culture, and politics.

Subscribe to stay informed whenever I publish new content. I never send spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime—no strings attached.

Go back

Your message has been sent

Email me at jvh@alumni.stanford.edu