The Silenced Warning: What Briseis Can Teach Us About Betrayal

4–6 minutes

·

·

In Homer’s Iliad, Briseis is a Trojan woman captured in war. She doesn’t command armies. She doesn’t give orders. And yet, in modern retellings—those that center her perspective—Briseis becomes something else entirely.

She becomes a witness.

Not to triumph, but to betrayal.

She watches the people around her posture and scheme. She sees the shifting alliances. She senses when someone is about to break ranks. She knows—long before the battle lines are drawn—how it’s all going to fall apart.

But no one thinks to ask her.

And more importantly, no one understands she’s trying to say something.

Briseis is not a prophet. She is not a saboteur. She is not even silenced in the traditional sense. She simply knows what’s coming—and can’t say it in a way that power knows how to hear.

That’s where it gets uncomfortable.

Because the Briseis may have tried to warn you.

And you didn’t see it.

Not because you were arrogant.

But because you didn’t realize what the warning looked like until it was too late.

The People Who Tried to Warn You—but Couldn’t

Briseis isn’t just a figure in mythology. She’s very real.

She’s who lingered in your doorway after a meeting, her posture off, her tone uncertain.

She’s someone from down the hall who said, “Some things feel strange right now,” and quickly changed the subject.

She’s the administrative assistant who noticed a pattern change in meetings or emails.

She’s the colleague who privately asked you noticeably too many questions about a minor policy shift—because she wanted you to sense it wasn’t so minor.

At the time, you didn’t see it for what it was.

You didn’t know they were trying to warn you.

And then, weeks or days later, the betrayal happened.

And as you sat there processing it, you thought back to those moments—and realized:

She knew. She tried. I just didn’t recognize it.

Briseis Stopped By—More Than Once

You remember now.

It wasn’t just one interaction. It wasn’t a single cryptic comment or a strange pause in a meeting. It was a pattern. A subtle, quiet pattern that didn’t register until much later.

She stopped by your office several times.

Never on your calendar. Never with a formal reason.

Just to “check in.”

She stood in the doorway with that soft, searching expression and said something like, “How are you doing?”

She asked about something small—an upcoming meeting, a recent decision, a team dynamic. She mentioned a colleague. It all seemed casual. Unimportant. Friendly.

But it wasn’t.

Looking back, you know it now: she was trying to warn you.

Not to undermine anyone. Not to gossip.

But because she cared.

She didn’t feel safe saying it outright. She wasn’t sure if you’d believe her. She wasn’t high enough in the hierarchy to speak without risk. So she showed up the only way she could: gently, carefully, hoping you’d hear the warning hidden in the quiet.

She covered it with concern.

She veiled it in small talk.

But what she was really saying—again and again—was this:

“Please notice. Something’s coming. And I can’t say it out loud.”

She was yelling quietly.

And you didn’t know how to hear her.

Now, after everything, you remember those unscheduled visits with a sinking feeling: they were the most important meetings you never wrote down.

Why We Miss the Briseis Warning

It’s not because we’re not listening. It’s because we’re not trained to interpret subtle truth.

Work is noisy. We are taught to respond to formal challenges: memos, grievances, official reports, petitions, loud stakeholders, policy debates. But Briseis doesn’t speak that way.

She doesn’t issue a warning in all-caps. She doesn’t file a complaint. She gives you a glance. A moment of hesitation. A strange energy shift in the room. A quiet visit when things feel like they’re changing.

And unless you’ve learned to see it, you don’t.

That’s not a failure of compassion.

It’s a failure of life literacy.

And it’s one of the hardest truths a person has to face: you missed the warning. Not because it wasn’t there—but because you didn’t know what to look for.

What Briseis Teaches Us About Working Smarter

Briseis doesn’t exist to shame you. She’s not a symbol of your failure. She’s a teacher.

She teaches us that in every institution, there are people who know more than they can say. People who are too marginalized, too politicized, too exposed to speak the truth directly.

But they try.

And if we’re wise, we’ll start learning how to listen to those warnings—before hindsight teaches us the hard way. Not all intelligence comes in reports.

Institutional truth lives in how people move, show up, and stay silent.

Treat body language, hesitation, and emotional tone as valid data—especially from people who don’t have extensive formal power but carry social awareness.

Sometimes Briseis only tries once. And sometimes she tries more than once—but never gets through. If you misread her, she may not come back. Next time she sees betrayal forming, she may just watch. She already tried. You weren’t ready.

Briseis Doesn’t Whisper Because She’s Weak

Briseis doesn’t whisper because that’s the only way she’s been allowed to speak. Her quiet isn’t weakness. It’s care. Its conviction pressed through a filter of power. And when someone like her shows up in your doorway, checks in “just to say hi,” lingers a second longer than necessary—you have a choice. You can smile, say “Thanks for stopping in,” and get back to your tasks. Or you can pause. Lean in.

Because she might be trying to save you from something you can’t yet see.

Final Thoughts

A thank you to My Briseis: I’m sorry I didn’t understand in the moment. But I do now. And I won’t miss it next time.

May we all learn to see and hear Briseis when they come.

In Homer’s Iliad, Briseis is a Trojan woman captured in war. She doesn’t command armies. She doesn’t give orders. And yet, in modern retellings—those that center her perspective—Briseis becomes something else entirely. She becomes a witness. Not to triumph, but to betrayal. She watches the people around her posture and scheme. She sees the shifting…

2 responses to “The Silenced Warning: What Briseis Can Teach Us About Betrayal”

  1. Christine Langhoff Avatar
    Christine Langhoff

    Thank you for this, Julian. Like Briseis, it’s powerful

    Like

  2. Mary A Climer Avatar

    💙Sent from my iPhone

    Like

Leave a reply to Mary A Climer Cancel reply

Cloaking Inequity is an online platform for justice and liberty-minded readers. I publish reflections, analysis, and commentary on education, democracy, culture, and politics.

Subscribe to stay informed whenever I publish new content. I never send spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime—no strings attached.

Go back

Your message has been sent

Email me at jvh@alumni.stanford.edu