How Trump Cancelled Diversity in Three Easy Steps (And Lost in Court)

6–10 minutes

·

·

You spent years earning the approval of scientific experts. They spent minutes asking ChatGPT whether the word equity was a national security threat. Welcome to American research policy in an era of Trump, where a doctorate takes six years, but dismantling someone else’s scholarship apparently requires only seconds, Wi-Fi, a temporary government email address, and absolutely no sense of liberty and the Constitution.

Here’s how it began. Twenty-something tech bros from Trump’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) showed up, opened ChatGPT, and apparently used keywords to decide that some research is too diverse. No dissertation required. No peer review necessary. Just an AI chatbot, a list of politically suspicious DEI words, and the confidence of self-appointed experts who apparently believed that knowing how to write a prompt qualified them to overrule scholars who spent their careers learning how to conduct scientific research.

And here’s an update to the story. On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to hear the Trump administration’s appeal in a case involving research funding canceled because of its perceived connections to diversity, equity, and inclusion. No explanation. Not even one noted dissent (Alito?! Thomas!?). Just a one-line order leaving court protections for University of California researchers in place. For an administration determined to cancel diversity, the Supreme Court momentarily became an inconvenient customer service department.

Step One: Hire Two Guys and Ask ChatGPT What Diversity Means

According to ABC News, DOGE employees Nate Cavanaugh and Justin Fox helped review thousands of National Endowment for the Humanities grants for potential cancellation. Their process included keyword searches and ChatGPT, which Fox used to identify projects that might be associated with DEI. There was one small problem: They reportedly never gave ChatGPT a clear definition of DEI.

Think about that. The federal government was using artificial intelligence to help terminate research grants based on a concept its own “employees” couldn’t clearly define. That’s like asking a Dallas Cowboys fan to explain what it takes to win a Super Bowl, then putting them in charge of choosing plays in the games. Plenty of confidence, absolutely no relevant experience. J-Lo has more rings than the Cowboys since the 1990s. But I digress.

The results were predictable in the least reassuring sense. A documentary about Holocaust survivors was identified as potentially DEI-related. During a deposition, Fox was questioned about why such a project had been flagged, exposing the absurdity of treating research about a particular community as inherently suspect. By that standard, The Diary of Anne Frank might need a disclaimer for excessive attention to one demographic. Black History Month might need to become General History Month, and the Smithsonian might have to rename half its museums the National Museum of People Who Lived at Some Point.

Step Two: Cancel the Grants.

During depositions reported by ABC News, Cavanaugh defended DOGE’s grant cancellations as part of an effort to reduce federal spending. When questioned about the consequences for people who lost income, he maintained that reducing the deficit was more important. Then came a follow-up that was awkward for him: Had DOGE actually reduced the deficit? He acknowledged that it had not.

Imagine trying that explanation at a university budget meeting. You eliminate graduate assistantships, use an AI software program to close majors, terminate community partnerships, offer early retirement, combine communications efforts across campus, and announce that the sacrifices were necessary to improve the institution’s finances. Then the faculty senate and union asks whether the budget actually improved, and you explain that the important thing was demonstrating a commitment to efficiency. As a former provost, I can assure you that there would be follow-up questions.

There’s another irony. Donald Trump has a history of disputes over paying people for work they performed. In 2016, many media outlets reported allegations involving unpaid contractors, including a piano dealer and a family-owned cabinetry business. Trump disputed some claims, arguing that certain contractors had performed unsatisfactory work. Now the payment disputes involve university researchers rather than casino contractors. The legal circumstances are different, but the recurring question is familiar: What happens when people have already performed work or made commitments based on promised payment?

This time, the researchers had constitutional arguments, federal judges, and attorneys willing to test Trump’s actions in court. In May 2026, U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon ruled that DOGE’s mass cancellation of more than $100 million in humanities grants was unlawful and unconstitutional. Her decision found violations of the First Amendment and the equal-protection component of the Fifth Amendment, along with a lack of statutory authority for DOGE to direct the cancellations. Apparently, “ChatGPT looked for DEI words” is not an exemption from the Bill of Rights.

Step Three: Hope the Universities Are Too Scared to Fight Back

This may have been the most reliable part of the administration’s strategy, although it’s difficult to measure how much institutional silence was driven by fear, agreement, or legal advice. Across higher education, universities have closed ethnic and gender studies majors, renamed programs and positions, revised websites, and reconsidered community commitments they had celebrated only months earlier. Some leaders undoubtedly believed they were protecting their institutions from political retaliation. Others may have believed the DEI policy changes were highly desired and something they’d wanted to do for a long time.

I have spent enough time in university leadership meetings to recognize what institutional risk avoidance looks like. In allot of somewheres, I imagine a university committee has been assembled to determine whether the word equity can safely remain in its strategic plan. The committee has twelve members, three subcommittees, an outside consultant, a six-month timeline with sandwich orders scheduled. Their first recommendation will probably be to rename the committee.

Meanwhile, researchers at the University of California went to court. I appreciate leaders who have defended their faculty and institutional independence, including Harvard’s willingness to pursue litigation on multiple fronts. Harvard has challenged federal actions involving research funding, international students, and university autonomy. Those cases involve distinct legal questions, but the institution has demonstrated an intense willingness to contest actions it believes exceed federal authority and the Constitution.

I have been less impressed with Stanford, my alma mater. President Jonathan Levin and Provost Jenny Martinez have publicly defended Harvard and the independence of universities, which deserves acknowledgment. But statements alone are not the full measure of institutional courage. The Stanford alumni-led coalition Cardinal Courage has urged the university to take stronger legal action to protect academic freedom, student privacy, and institutional autonomy. I appreciate alumni who are willing to ask difficult questions of institutions they love.

I understand why university presidents worry about federal political retaliation. Billions in research dollars support laboratories, faculty, students, and communities. Litigation is expensive, and universities have complicated obligations that cannot be resolved through slogans. But a university cannot defend academic freedom entirely through carefully worded press releases or silence. At some point, leadership requires deciding which commitments are worth defending legally when not doing so becomes a hinderance on their creation of knowledge.

The Courts Didn’t Follow the Script

The November 2026 Supreme Court action concerned a different lawsuit from the DOGE humanities case. University of California researchers challenged the termination of grants awarded by the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities, arguing that the government had targeted their work because of viewpoints it disliked.

The appeal involved roughly $150 million in originally awarded grants, with approximately $59 million remaining when the agencies terminated the relevant awards. The Ninth Circuit concluded that the researchers were likely to succeed on their First Amendment claims.

The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the appeal was not a final ruling on every constitutional question related to DEI. It left the preliminary protections in place rather than delivering a sweeping judgment about future federal research priorities. Still, the practical lesson is significant. Federal agencies can establish lawful funding priorities, but their decisions remain subject to constitutional constraints.

Conclusion: Diversity Is Still Here. Apparently, So Is the Constitution.

So there you have it: Three easy steps to cancel diversity. Hire two guys with ChatGPT. Cut the funding. Pray nobody calls a lawyer. Unfortunately for the administration, California’s researchers skipped the obligatory six-month university task force and went straight to court. The Supreme Court declined to intervene.

Perhaps the DOGE employees should have asked ChatGPT one more question before canceling their Plus subscriptions, and those research grants: Can the federal government punish researchers for expressing viewpoints it doesn’t like? Instead of searching grant proposals for suspicious words like diversity, equity, and inclusion, perhaps they should have searched the Constitution for one word that actually matters: LIBERTY. Turns out, you can cancel an AI subscription. You can temporarily cancel a “DEI” grant. But you can’t cancel the Constitution.

Please share.


Julian Vasquez Heilig is a nationally recognized public scholar, commentator, and civil rights advocate whose work has appeared on Democracy Now!, MSNBC, Al Jazeera, NBC News, PBS, and Univision. He brings clarity, urgency, and public relevance to complex issues in education, policy, and leadership. For consulting, speaking opportunities, and collaborations, contact jvh@alumni.stanford.edu.

You spent years earning the approval of scientific experts. They spent minutes asking ChatGPT whether the word equity was a national security threat. Welcome to American research policy in an era of Trump, where a doctorate takes six years, but dismantling someone else’s scholarship apparently requires only seconds, Wi-Fi, a temporary government email address, and…

Leave a Reply

Cloaking Inequity is an online platform for justice and liberty-minded readers. I publish reflections, analysis, and commentary on education, democracy, culture, and politics.

Subscribe to stay informed whenever I publish new content. I never send spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime—no strings attached.

Email me at jvh@alumni.stanford.edu