Decade of Education Outcome Data: Texas vs. California vs. New York vs. Nation

img-below-nav

Today we are pleased to release the report Is Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data. The Institute for Urban Policy Research and Analysis at the University of Texas at Austin commissioned a policy this report in the spring of 2012 to examine education data for the state of Texas, its peers and the nation. In this report, we gather data from a variety of sources to understand student outcomes in elementary, secondary and higher education by race and ethnicity for the past decade. We believe this is the first report to gather educational data of these types all in one report.

What did we find? (The Executive Summary)

The Texas Education Agency’s (TEA) Texas Assessment of Academic Skills (TAAS) and Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS) exit exam data show that African American and Latina/o students apparently made dramatic achievement gains and narrowed the achievement gaps during the TAAS and TAKS eras. Notably, these gains appear to be reflected in the national NAEP test scores as Texas had the highest 4th grade and 8th grade NAEP scale scores relative to its peer states of New York and California for African Americans and Latina/os.

However, while the achievement gap closes, overall student performance lags.  This is not unique to Texas; each of the most populous states performed worse over the past decade relative to other states in the nation. Texas dropped 21 spots in 4th grade math, four spots in 4th grade reading, and eight spots in 8th grade reading. The only bright spot was that Texas improved its standing by the end of the decade in 8th grade math, moving from 22nd to 18th.

Education policy has not only focused on academic achievement, as measured by test scores, but has also focused on drop out and graduation rates. Despite about 15 years of high-stakes testing and accountability policy, dropout rates and graduation rates for African Americans in Texas do not appear to have improved; in fact, if data from independent empirical sources noted in the report are to be believed, the situation has worsened.

Another important question is whether Texas’ early grade performance on standardized tests relative to peer states also transferred to college entrance exams. Overall ACT composite scores were highest in New York (ranked 4th), followed California (15th) and then Texas (33rd). For African Americans and Latina/os, New York students had the highest ACT composite scores followed by California, then Texas. For the SAT, we found that California had the highest scores followed by Texas and then New York. Only California increased their SAT composite scores (2 points) over the last decade with other two states showing decreases New York (-17 points) and Texas (-4 points). In terms of national rank, California’s SAT rank held steady at 35th in the nation followed by Texas (44th) and New York (47th). In 2009, for African Americans and Latina/os, Texas had the highest SAT composite scores for Latinos amongst peer states, while California had the highest composite scores for African Americans. Therefore, in sum, Texas apparent success in the state-level data released to the public and NEAP scores in elementary and middle school is largely not reflected in composite SAT or ACT scores— except for Latina/os

These results beg the question: Why, considering in the past 20 years of high-stakes testing and accountability policy in the state, have these policies not produced more competitive NAEP scores relative to the nation and greater levels of college readiness in Texas relative to peer states and all other states? Considering that the ultimate goal of our schools is frequently framed as college and career readiness by the legislature, it appears that our current system is not meeting those goals, but state-mandated tests (TAAS, TAKS, STAAR— even NAEP) are instead providing us a false sense of security regarding achievement our schools.

In terms of higher education outcomes, Texas, in comparison to its peer states, finds itself generally surpassing California, but trails New York in virtually all outcomes. New York’s performance on higher education measures suggests that policies in that state are generally assisting African American and Latina/o students in closing the gaps. New York students generally surpassed California and Texas students on every measure, save one very significant exception: New York students allocated far greater amounts of their income toward higher education costs. While this finding is troubling to an extent, students’ aspirations towards higher education, as well as the amount of time they spend outside of class devoted towards studying is noteworthy. Higher education remediation measures are a category that none of the comparison states can truly boast about. In California, New York, and Texas, all three states reported that approximately half of all African American and Latina/o students had taken remedial courses. This speaks to the inequity of educational opportunities before students get to college.

In conclusion, while Texas typically performs in the middle between New York and California on the K-12 and higher education measures, the state is seeing more trends of decline and stasis than growth between 2000 and 2010 relative to all states in the nation. To promote college and career readiness, policymakers need more policy research to help them pinpoint problems and potential solutions.  This report is an example of the beginning of research that illuminates public issues in education but much more is necessary. The analyses in this report find indicate that Texas must stop depending solely on high-stakes testing as a measuring stick of the state’s educational progress and get serious about funding our schools (K-12 and higher education) relative to other states in the nation . California, in this instance, may serve as a bellwether demonstrating the catastrophic effects of extended divestment in education.

Cite as: Vasquez Heilig, J., Jez, S. & Reddick, R. (2012). Is Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data. The Institute for Urban Policy Research and Analysis. University of Texas at Austin.

About these ads

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Categories: Accountability, African Americans, Announcements, High-Stakes Testing, Higher Education Access, Latina/os

Author:Julian Vasquez Heilig

Julian Vasquez Heilig is currently an Associate Professor of Educational Policy and Planning and African and African Diaspora Studies (by courtesy) at the University of Texas at Austin.

Social Media

Subscribe to my RSS feed and social profiles to receive updates.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. You saw it here first! | Cloaking Inequity - October 16, 2012

    [...] official press release is now available for the Texas vs. California vs. New York vs. Nation educational outcomes policy report. You the readers of Cloaking Inequity saw it here [...]

  2. Lurking in the Bushes: Peeking at Florida Education Miracle | Cloaking Inequity - November 28, 2012

    [...] we were preparing the Education: Texas vs. California vs. New York vs. Nation policy brief, we also concurrently gathered data for Florida that ultimately ended up on the [...]

  3. Guess which state is 3rd “Dumbest in the Nation”?! | Cloaking Inequity - December 10, 2012

    [...] Edit 12/9/2012: For a decadal analysis of Texas K-12 and Higher Education data go here. [...]

  4. Texas Enrontizes Federal Graduation Data? | Cloaking Inequity - January 14, 2013

    [...] the ACGR go here). This would be a miraculous achievement for the Lone Star State. As we show in Is Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data, Texas’ Averaged Freshman Graduation Rate (AFGR) was 75.4% as recently as three years ago [...]

  5. Kress is Wrong on Tests: Our Accountability System Must Evolve | Cloaking Inequity - January 24, 2013

    [...] of Texas at Austin’s Institute for Urban Policy Research & Analysis (IUPRA) entitled Is Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data found that over the past decade Texas dropped 21 spots in 4th grade math, four spots in 4th grade [...]

  6. The High-Stakes Testing Playbook: False Bill of Goods? | Cloaking Inequity - January 25, 2013

    [...] years providing the appearance of improvement year after year. Meanwhile, as we showed in our report examining the past decade of Texas education data, over the past decade, independent national exams [...]

  7. Help Has Arrived!: Banishing NCLB’s Narrow Paradigm | Cloaking Inequity - February 6, 2013

    [...] report Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data reported that over the past decade Texas dropped 21 spots in 4th grade math, four spots in 4th [...]

  8. Soiled Legacy: The Birth of No Child Left Behind in Texas | Cloaking Inequity - February 17, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  9. With Bush’s ‘Texas Miracle’ debunked, Lone Star State sparks anti-testing revolution — MSNBC - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but overall Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas. But by then it was too [...]

  10. With Bush’s ‘Texas Miracle’ debunked, Lone Star State sparks anti-testing revolution | News Sandbox - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but overall Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas. But by then it was too [...]

  11. Bush’s ‘Texas Miracle’ debunked, Lone Star State sparks anti-testing revolution | Now - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but overall Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas. But by then it was too [...]

  12. Knews Feed » Jason Stanford: Is Texas Ending High-Stakes Testing? - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  13. Stanford and Dropouts: “Perry Makes Galveston Disappear” | Cloaking Inequity - February 18, 2013

    [...] 29th in graduation rate. Increasing the percentage of kids you move through high school from 75.4% to 86% is big news, no matter what the [...]

  14. Jason Stanford: Is Texas Ending High-Stakes Testing? : freedomluchador.com - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  15. Jason Stanford: Is Texas Ending High-Stakes Testing? | Elm River Free Press - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  16. Jason Stanford: Is Texas Ending High-Stakes Testing? | Political Ration - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  17. Jason Stanford: Is Texas Ending High-Stakes Testing? | Tiggio Blogs and More - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  18. Jason Stanford: Is Texas Ending High-Stakes Testing? | News Talk One - February 18, 2013

    [...] Progress scores to show progress, but over all Texas lost ground to the rest of the country, found Dr. Julian V. Heilig, an education researcher at the University of Texas, but by then it was too [...]

  19. Testing and Accountability Testimony to TX House Public Ed Committee | Cloaking Inequity - February 19, 2013

    [...] of Texas at Austin’s Institute for Urban Policy Research & Analysis (IUPRA) entitled Is Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data found that over the past decade Texas dropped 21 spots in 4th grade math, four spots in 4th grade [...]

  20. Why We Were Led Astray On Education « kavips - February 19, 2013

    [...] to Julian Helig, who released this report to examine the education for the Texas [...]

  21. Jason Stanford: How Rick Perry Solved the Dropout Problem by Making Galveston Disappear | Political Ration - February 20, 2013

    [...] ranked 29th in graduation rate. Increasing the percentage of kids you move through high school from 75.4 percent to 86 percent is big news, no matter what the [...]

  22. Meta: Education on the cheap? | Cloaking Inequity - February 25, 2013

    [...] STAAR) scores have (or will) go through the roof and that the achievement gap is closing rapidly, our research has shown that NAEP, SAT, and ACT scores relative to the nation have barley budged and the gap remains over [...]

  23. How the Left Say Thank You for Your Help. - Page 7 - March 6, 2013

    [...] [...]

  24. Invited Testimony: Same Shift, Different Day for Latinos and African Americans | Cloaking Inequity - November 24, 2013

    […] is also problematic if Texas hopes to compete with Common Core states on the SAT and ACT (See also Education Outcomes: Texas vs. California vs. New York vs. Nation) because those students will have access to Algebra II. It’s the same shift, different […]

  25. Were kids actually smarter decades ago?: Student achievement data trends (NAEP, etc.) | Cloaking Inequity - February 4, 2014

    […] national standards for levels of proficiency (For an analysis of SAT and ACT data check out Education Outcomes: Texas vs. California vs. New York vs. Nation). Examining the NAEP and other national test results also allows comparison of  Texas’ […]

  26. Uncovering Lies and Damn Lies in Arne Duncan’s Graduation Rates | Cloaking Inequity - May 7, 2014

    […] the ACGR go here). This would be a miraculous achievement for the Lone Star State. As we show in Is Texas leading its peers and the nation?: A Decadal Analysis of Educational Data, Texas’ Averaged Freshman Graduation Rate (AFGR) was 75.4% as recently as three years ago and […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 5,785 other followers

%d bloggers like this: