Breaking News: NEA makes STRONG, patriotic statement on charters

I am not able to blog as much as I have in the past because of my faculty responsibilities at California State, public speaking engagements and contributing behind the scenes to game-changing projects. One of the game-changing projects that I have worked on over the past several months was the NEA Charter Taskforce. As the token academic on the taskforce, I travelled to taskforce meetings several times over the past six months or so. Here is a shot of the taskforce members sent to me by a NEA RA delegate from the floor (I didn’t circle me).


Why is the statement from the NEA important now? Mike Petrilli recently argued in USAToday that education reform has been “mainstream” movement over the past 15 years. During the Senate confirmation hearing for Betsy DeVos, Lamar Alexander essentially made the same argument on behalf of vouchers and charters. Education reformer’s goals are far from mainstream, they are in fact sea-changing neoliberal ideals for private control of education. I believe what is happening is that supporters of democratic control of public schools are realizing this insidious goal and are now taking a critical look at school choice. The public is becoming more and more aware that the arguments that underly the various private-control and privatzatition school choice approaches are red herrings. Even Last Week Tonight has taken notice.

The key issue in our schools has been and continues to be severe inequality in schools that is perpetrated on purpose. Furthermore, the outcry against the privatization and private control of our schools via charters and vouchers has gathered steam as communities have asked to choose from democratically-controlled alternatives— and privatizers have refused.

Back to the NEA vote.

The statement that was originally designed and submitted by the taskforce was amended today at the RA. I was getting texts live from the floor of the RA and was concerned about some of the proposed amendments. However, most that made it through in my view made the statement on charters from America’s educators stronger.

See the final approved statement here:

For example, I think the call for a moratorium from the BATs is important because many choice supporters continue to deflect and ignore important critiques. Additionally, the moratorium amendment echoes and supports the resolution passed by the NAACP at our national convention last year.

Here is an excerpt from the official press release:

The new policy statement lays out three criteria that charter schools must meet to provide students with the support and learning environments they deserve:

  • Charter schools must be authorized and held accountable by the local school board as only a local, democratically accountable authorizing entity can ensure that a charter is actually needed to meet student needs in a way that other alternatives available to the district could not, and only a local authorizer can monitor charter performance on an ongoing basis to ensure accountability and spread charter innovations to other public schools.
  • The charter school must demonstrate that it is necessary to meet the needs of the students in the district, and they must meet those needs in a manner that improves the local public school system.
  • The charter school must comply with the same basic safeguards as other public schools. This includes open meetings and public records laws, prohibitions against for-profit operations or profiteering, and the same civil rights, employment, labor, health and safety laws and staff qualification and certification requirements as other public schools.

Charter schools that do not meet these criteria do more harm than good to students, neighborhood public schools, and the cause of public education.

I believe that the NEA RA statement on charters is a big step in the right direction for our national discourse about the privatization and private-control of our education system. Fomenting democracy and education on the 4th of July! What could be more patriotic!!!

Please Facebook Like, Tweet, etc below and/or reblog to share this discussion with others.

Check out and follow my YouTube channel here.

Want to know about Cloaking Inequity’s freshly pressed conversations about educational policy? Click the “Follow blog by email” button in the upper left hand corner of this page.

Twitter: @ProfessorJVH

Click here for Vitae.


  • Sad comment that NEA found room for only a token academic on its Charter School Task Force. But, my sense is Dr.Vasquez-Heilig did a hella job in bringing deep scholarly understand of the drain on public schools that the Specter of charter school growth presents.

    The existential threat that charter school growth present to public education must be resisted, as the NEA’s future as a viable union, capable of defending its members from privatization, is in the balance.


  • How does the NEA position differ from the one Randi Weingarten articulated in her LA Times op/ed piece with Josh Edelman?


  • Not to take it there, but it’s good to see we got some people of color helping to lead these national discussions. Every once in awhile I check out who is on the board of directors of some groups and it’s not as diverse as one would wish.

    Let’s hope that we can move it forward with this NEA push.

    Liked by 1 person

  • Ncessary clarity, as usual. “Education reformer’s goals are far from mainstream, they are in fact sea-changing neoliberal ideals for private control of education.” THANK YOU.

    Liked by 1 person

  • It took long enough for the NEA to start to wake up.

    I suspected something was going on back in the 1980s all the way to my retirement from teaching in 2005, but I convinced myself it was all my imagination, a conspiracy theory of my own making. I mean, the evidence was everywhere, but who could be that evil, that corrupt, that greedy.

    And then I read Diane Ravitch and started following her Blog. Now I know who many of the major scallywags are behind the privatization movement of K-12 education in the US, and they have all earned the privilege of being boiled in oil before the guillotine is brought out of its long retirement and used to help remove the misery that follows these frauds around like clouds of smelly noxious fumes behind an old polluting diesel trucks.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s