Water into Wine?: Jeb Bush, Cheapistas, and Educational Reform

Screen Shot 2013-02-27 at 10.48.55 PM

Jeb is in the building. Another Bush (and his junior) is in the capitol today in Austin to discuss the education miracle that Florida purportedly achieved on the cheap.

As discussed yesterday, there is a cadre of politicians that believe we can get something for nothing. That we can do education cheaper and cheaper. That we can cut billions and billions from education budgets without any impact on our children. What is common in ALL of the cheapistas (new word for educational reformistas who believe we can turnaround education on the cheap) proposals is that we can save the taxpayers a buck and skyrocket test scores if we just adopt X (online education, vouchers, charters etc. etc.). The Jeb Bush posse from Florida has been essentially arguing this logic trail nonstop. Whether it is Jeb’s Education Foundation that was discussed here, or former Jeb underlings that I have encountered— the basic narrative is that Florida turned water in wine— a miracle.

Cloaking Inequity examined the purported test score miracle earlier here. In 4th grade, Florida improved over the last decade and was position in the top ten nationally, but as you move up the grade levels, the longer student stay in Florida schools, the worse their performance relative to the nation. I also discussed the official Florida scholarship evaluation in Florida that showed their scholarship (aka neovoucher) program had not increased the achievement of program participants.

The National Education Policy Center has also looked at the data from Florida and studied the Heritage Foundation’s glowing analysis of Florida’s educational reforms. Their conclusion:

The central analysis compares average test scores of students in the nation versus Florida without considering key group differences, an oversight that leads to erroneous causal interpretations on effects of reforms using purely descriptive data. The report further ignores group differences resulting from the state’s mandatory grade retention policy for the weakest readers in grade 3. This policy-driven increase in grade retention rates spuriously inflated the average scores of grade 4 students on state and national assessments, making racial achievement gaps narrower. The report also fails to examine test score data on all subjects and grade levels, instead relying only on grade 4 reading, which showed the most positive results. Finally, although a great deal is known about the reform policies the report promotes, it neglects this research literature. These serious flaws call into question the report’s conclusions.

Now it is true that the U.S. is typically one of the top three highest spending nations on education, yet our international test scores are only top ten. Check out this infographic from USC. However, we must remember we ask our schools to provide many social services that governments in other nations subsidize outside of schools. We also fund transportation, food service and a variety of expensive extracurricular such high school football. Also, the funding is averaged per pupil— that means that some districts have quite a bit more resources than others to educated their students which foments large achievement disparities. When it comes to teachers, the New York Times reported that international data also show that U.S. teacher salaries compared to GDP are lower than in other countries. So while the common refrain from cheapistas is that the U.S. at or near the top in education spending, its a deceptive statement.

Note to Cheapistas: As my mother always says, “If it is too good to be true, it probably isn’t.”


Categories: Charter Schools, School Finance, Vouchers

Author:Julian Vasquez Heilig

Julian Vasquez Heilig is an award-winning researcher and teacher. He is currently a Professor of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies and the Director of the Doctorate in Educational Leadership at California State Sacramento.

Social Media



  1. Turning Water into Wine: The Florida Faux Miracle | Diane Ravitch's blog - March 1, 2013

    […] Vasquez Heilig of the University of Texas is one of our greatest debunkers of educational miracles. And what good timing, because Jeb Bush was in town to tout the Florida miracle, where (he say) test scores go up as costs go down. It’s all a matter of more testing, more […]

  2. If it ain’t broke, break it: TX politicians now want NCLB for higher education | Cloaking Inequity - March 15, 2013

    […] University of Texas System, Texas A&M System, Sul Ross, University of Houston etc. While the cheapistas are not trotting out the monikers No College Student Left Behind or accountability, the use of […]

  3. Just Say No to Just Read, Florida, South Carolina | the becoming radical - April 1, 2013

    […] Julian Vasquez Heilig identifies the error of focusing on apparent increases in 3rd to 4th grade reading scores and associating them with policy: […]

  4. The BEAST | The Definitive 2013 Guide to the 2016 Republican Presidential Frontrunners, Part II - April 1, 2013

    […] While he supposedly ran and operated as a moderate Republican (by today’s standards, anyways), Jeb’s governorship brought about a slew of reactionary policies. He used an executive order to trash Florida’s Affirmative Action laws, replacing it with his controversial “One Florida Initiative.” He was also key in the media circus and religious pandering that ensured that Terry Schaivo’s drooling mug wouldn’t die with dignity. Now the head of the charter school think-tank education policy organization Foundation for the Excellence in Education (FEE), Jeb is touting the Florida school “reform” plan he enacted as governor. The same plan being mimicked by government officials everywhere. So, ya know, blame Jeb. […]

  5. Retain to Impede: When Reading Legislation Fails (Again) | the becoming radical - February 19, 2014

    […] Water into Wine?, Julian Vasquez Heilig […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 7,706 other followers

%d bloggers like this: